Throughout the Series Edit
In Coral Palms Pt. 2, he stops Jake and Holt for running a stop sign and then sees the arsenal they bought in the back seat. He also gets Jake and Holt to play "The Newlywed Game" to see if their story matches. Jake and Holt get locked in a cell after Jake gets an answer wrong.
To get him to open the lock, Holt and Jake start a fight but Sheriff Reynolds only tries to interfere when Jake and Holt kiss.
In Coral Palms Pt. 3, he is shown in an interview about Jake and Holt's escape.
He appears again while Jake had Figgis held at gunpoint. After Jake drops his gun, he is then shot by Figgis. Amy later tells Jake that Sheriff Reynolds seems to be doing fine as he keeps saying, "Disability for life!".