Dan "Fingers" McCreary is a man Rosa has arrested twice for pickpocketing. In Halloween II Jake puts "Fingers" to use by hiring him to steal Captain Holt's watch in order to win their bet. It is however later revealed that Captain Holt had hired him to take his watch and hide it in his pocket so that it never leaves his person.
- He is portrayed by Apollo Robbins, an actual sleight of hand artist.
- Although his name is stated as Dan McCreary in dialog, the end credits state his name as Eric "Fingers" Martin. His spoken name is likely a reference to show writer Laura McCreary.