|Occupation:||Former Captain of The 99th Precinct|
|Last Appearance:||The Tagger|
|No. of Episodes:||2|
|Portrayed by:||Mike Hagerty|
As captain, he had a lax attitude that was appreciated by Jake. While Jake liked Captain McGintley because it meant he could do what he want, Amy took an opposing view, stating that he was a terrible captain.
Jake said 'McGinley would literally let you do anything you wanted if you gave him a hamburger' '... He was always an hour late... and hung over'.
He was willing to let the Nine-Nine do whatever they wanted and was often oblivious to what they were doing. In the pilot it's shown that the nine nine were doing a 'fire extinguisher roller chair derby'. After asking 'what the hell is going on in here', McGintley calmly says 'okay' and returns to his office.